Showing posts with label robinson. Show all posts
Showing posts with label robinson. Show all posts

Thursday, October 13, 2011

10b5 Scores - Argumentative Essay: Ken Robinson on Creativity

I apologize for the amount of time it's taking to get things graded, but Seniors are dominating my time with college essays and letters, and November 1st is their deadline. 

10b5 is coming along nicely, and I like what I see on the blogs.  Try to post reading journals AS you read - and not three weeks later. Remember, these are up to you to complete at your own pace, and you should write at least two for Shawshank - one about the book and one about the film and book compared.   If you haven't written one about the book it is probably too late, so try to make a better one to compensate about the film and book.

As for "extra writing."  Reposting stuff from other classes is fine, but what I find really impressive is real extra writing that is obviously not something from last year or last week in Mr. Moon's class.  What I like to see are creative things, like what Jingyeong has done with her amazing photography, or even a poem like Sehee's.  Extra writing is writing for the sake of writing and should be fun, and 10b5 isn't writing as much as some of the other classes. 

Here are the scores.  Going up!  Keep in mind that Structure is an easy place to earn extra points simply by making your post look good.
 
10b5
Alias
Content/10 
Mechanics/10
Structure/5
 TOTAL/25 

Raven
9.0
9.1
4.4
22.5

Woodpecker
9.1
9.0
4.6
22.7

Crane
9.0
9.1
4.4
22.5

Pelican
9.3
9.3
4.7
23.3

Swan
9.1
9.0
4.7
22.8

Duck
9.1
9.1
4.6
22.8

Toucan
9.2
9.0
4.6
22.8

Falcon
9.4
9.0
4.8
23.2

Parrot
9.3
9.2
4.7
23.2

Budgie
9.1
9.0
4.6
22.7

Finch
9.2
8.9
4.7
22.8

Robin
9.0
8.9
4.6
22.5

Eagle
8.8
9.0
4.4
22.2

Hawk
9.3
9.3
4.7
23.3

For each assignment I'd like to highlight one student's paper as an example of quality work.  Because I feature it does not mean it's the absolute best essay of the bunch or the highest scoring, but there might be something that student did that I feel is worth looking at.

For this assignment I'd like to look at Jiseon's paper.   What makes this a strong essay is the amount of extra research she did to illustrate a well stated thesis which she discussed through posed questions.  Though she's not the best writer in terms of grammar, she is very good at getting to a point clearly and economically.  This essay is actually one of the shortest in the class at just over 600 words, but in this case "short and sweet" works and her arguments develop with outside sources.  Lot's of stats and pictures which enforce her views persuasively.  Though the font is a bit small, the post simply looks "good."  Organized, centered, and designed to deliver her message effectively.  And while I never said this was necessary, she even cited her sources!  The extra mile, in this case, has earned extra points.  So try to keep this in mind - essays on paper are soon to be a thing of the past.  Use the blog to maximize the impact of your writing by enriching it with pictures and links which help add oomph.

Good work everyone.

Thursday, September 8, 2011

Assignment #2: Argumentative Essay: Education and Creativity

For your second assignment, I'd like you to respond to Sir Ken Robinson's opinions in the following videos, and in an argumentative essay adopt a clear stance.  Since you are students yourselves, and are part of the generations he speaks of, you should be able to offer both your own personal experience and opinion quite easily.  Like he says about education, "it's one of those things that goes deep with people....Like religion, and money and other things."

At first I presented this assignment to you as a "mini assignment," but considering the response in class I'd like it to upgrade it to a formal assignment which you should take more seriously than the first.  My apologies to class B1 who I may have misled following my initial plan.  Many of you are finished already, and if that's the case you can consider it a "first draft" which you can expand on.  Most of you have written far more than what I first quoted, so I think this won't be a problem for you.  Keep in mind I've also given you plenty of more time.

Criteria

Tone: Argumentative
Word Count: At least 500 words (more is great).
Due for for ALL classes: Friday, September 23rd  


To get an A you can be proud of:

Do: 
  •   Post the video you reference most in your blog (or all of them).  
  •   Use 5 paragraph structure (or six or seven etc., but definitely not 3 or 4).
  •   Choose a title for your post, and make your post look good.  Formatting is important.
  •   Read and edit and clean things up.
  •   Try to quote Robinson or someone a little.
  •   Balance your view with an opposing view.
  •   Bookend your essay with a satisfying hook and conclusion.
  •   Appeal to a bit of ethos, pathos, and logos (I think Mr. Yoon covered that with you).
Don't:
  •  Copy and paste links into your work without hyper-linking. 
  •  Forget to address the source material.
  •  Be afraid to be personal and narrative
  •  Write a single word less than 500.  


Here are the videos.  The first one we watched in class.  I think it's his most entertaining speech, but the RSA Animate below is more informative.   



In the speech below,  we see Sir Ken Robinson returning to TED a few years later.  Has anything changed since his first speech?  Remember you can activate subtitles, and even read the entire transcript in just about any language. You can cut and paste from it to use in your essay if you want to quote something he says directly.


 Questions you may want to consider addressing:

As Korean students, do you feel your creativity has been suitably enhanced and encouraged since you were young? Does KMLA meet your creative needs? Is creativity overrated? Underrated? Suitably treated in Korea's progressing education system? Is it progressing?

You are welcome to tie in some outside sources if they help your points and synthesize an argument.  In fact, I encourage it to get more than just an A.

Here are some videos that I think provide some contrast: